- RNNs Vs LSTMs Vs GRUs Vs Transformers
π PART 1: Comparing RNN, LSTM, GRU, and Transformer Architectures for Language Modeling
| Feature | RNN | LSTM | GRU | Transformer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architecture Type | Sequential | Sequential with memory | Sequential with gates | Attention-based, fully parallel |
| Sequence Handling | Step-by-step | Step-by-step | Step-by-step | Entire sequence in parallel |
| Memory | Short-term | Long-term memory | Long-term (simplified) | Global attention |
| Vanishing Gradient | Severe | Mitigated | Mitigated | Avoided via residuals + attention |
| Parallelization | β No | β No | β No | β Yes |
| Long-range Dependencies | Poor | Moderate | Moderate | Excellent |
| Training Speed | Slow | Slower | Faster than LSTM | Fast (GPU/TPU optimized) |
| Scalability | Poor | Moderate | Moderate | Excellent |
| Parameter Sharing | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes (though often huge models) |
| Applications | Basic NLP tasks | MT, Speech, Captioning | Chatbots, TTS | All SOTA NLP tasks |
π PART 2: Why Transformers Outperform RNN-based Models
π 1. Parallelization vs Sequential Bottleneck
- RNN/LSTM/GRU: Process input sequentially (token by token), preventing parallelization.
- Transformer: Uses self-attention over all tokens β processes whole sequence in parallel.
β Result: Transformers are faster and utilize GPU/TPU acceleration better.
π§ 2. Modeling Long-Range Dependencies
- RNNs forget earlier context due to vanishing gradients.
- LSTM/GRU improve this with gating mechanisms.
- Transformer attention enables direct access to all tokens.
β Result: Transformers model global context more effectively.
π 3. Richer Representations via Attention
- Attention lets models focus on important words, regardless of position.
- Example: βThe dog, which was barking loudly, ran away.β β βranβ aligns with βdogβ.
β Result: Better handling of syntactic and semantic dependencies.
π 4. Scalability & Transfer Learning
- Transformers (e.g., GPT, BERT) scale with data/params.
- Pretraining β Fine-tuning paradigm dominates modern NLP.
β Result: One pretrained Transformer can be reused for many downstream tasks.
π§© 5. Modularity and Customization
- Transformers are modular: multi-head attention, rotary encoding, sparse layers, retrieval augmentation, etc.
β Result: Easier experimentation and SOTA innovations.